10 Home Renovation Mistakes That Will Cost You Big (and How to Avoid Them)
Home renovations are full of promise: you envision bright new kitchens, spa-like bathrooms, and spaces that finally feel like home. But there’s a less glossy side to remodeling that too many homeowners find out the hard way. The excitement fades quickly when your project runs months over schedule, costs double what you budgeted, or leaves you living in a construction zone with no working plumbing.
The truth? Renovation regrets are more common than people like to admit—and most of them stem from the same set of avoidable mistakes. At Roberts Construction Company, we’ve seen what works and what doesn’t, hundreds of times over. So let’s walk through ten common (and costly) pitfalls—and more importantly, how you can steer clear of them before swinging that first hammer.
1. Underestimating the Real Cost
Most homeowners start with a budget that reflects best-case scenarios. Unfortunately, that’s not how construction works. Unexpected issues pop up constantly: mold behind walls, outdated wiring, or supply chain delays that force you into higher-priced materials. A common rule of thumb? Add at least 10–20% to whatever number you think your project will cost. That contingency isn’t just for peace of mind, it’s a buffer between you and financial panic.
Also, don’t forget soft costs. Permits, temporary housing, increased utility bills, and delivery fees can quietly drain your budget while you’re focused on tile samples. Having a complete budget that includes both the visible and hidden expenses puts you in control and prevents hard decisions mid-project, like choosing between countertops or finishing the job on time.
2. Skipping the Planning Phase
We get it, you’re eager to get started. But skipping the planning phase is like building a house without blueprints. Vague ideas and Pinterest boards don’t replace detailed construction drawings, product selections, and a defined scope of work. Without them, you’ll find yourself making last-minute decisions under pressure, which almost always leads to regret.
A thoughtful planning phase should also include scheduling subcontractors, ordering long-lead materials early, and finalizing every fixture and finish before demo begins. If you think you’ll “figure it out as you go,” what you’ll really be doing is wasting time and money, and possibly redoing work. A good contractor will help you front-load these decisions to avoid chaos later.
3. Hiring the Wrong Contractor
Hiring based on the lowest bid is a fast way to end up with subpar work, or worse, unfinished work. Your contractor is more than a builder; they’re the quarterback of your entire project. If they’re unlicensed, uninsured, or can’t produce references, run. Reputable contractors will have a portfolio, client reviews, a clear contract, and proof of insurance. No exceptions.
Communication is also key. If they ghost you during the bidding phase or dodge detailed questions, imagine what’ll happen when problems arise mid-project. Always choose a contractor who’s responsive, transparent, and professional. Your home is too valuable to hand over to someone whose biggest selling point is “cheap.”
4. Going Too Trendy
Sure, that matte black faucet and chevron tile are hot right now. But will they still be stylish in five years, or scream “2020s renovation” to future buyers? While it’s tempting to chase trends, they tend to age poorly. Stick to classic materials and neutral palettes for big-ticket items like cabinetry and flooring. Save the trendy choices for paint colors and hardware that can be swapped out easily.
This isn’t about playing it safe, it’s about protecting your investment. Overly stylized renovations can alienate buyers and limit your resale value. Think about your future self (or the next buyer). Will they love it, or will they budget for the cost of undoing your statement wall?
5. Over-Renovating for the Neighborhood
It’s easy to get caught up in making your home the showstopper on the block, but there’s such a thing as over-improving. If your home becomes drastically more expensive than your neighbors’ due to high-end finishes or extensive upgrades, you may never see a return on investment when it’s time to sell.
Renovate with an eye on market norms. If homes in your area don’t have imported marble or smart toilets, yours probably doesn’t need them either. Instead, focus on quality craftsmanship and upgrades that match your neighborhood’s expectations. You can still have luxury, just don’t expect buyers to pay extra for features they didn’t ask for.
6. DIY-ing Past Your Skill Set
There’s nothing wrong with tackling some parts of a renovation yourself—paint, minor demo, maybe even tiling if you’ve done it before. But there’s a line, and it’s thinner than you think. Electrical, plumbing, structural changes, and anything involving permits should be left to professionals. Trying to save money with DIY shortcuts can actually cost you more in repairs or code violations later.
We’ve seen DIYers cut into load-bearing walls, wire outlets incorrectly, and forget about crucial waterproofing steps, only to call us months later with major damage. Know your limits. You’re not saving money if you have to pay twice to fix what you botched.
7. Forgetting About Permits
Permits are annoying, yes. But they’re also critical. Failing to pull proper permits can result in work stoppages, fines, failed inspections, or even insurance claim denials. Worse, if you sell your home and the buyer’s inspector finds unpermitted work, you could lose the sale—or be forced to rip everything out.
Permitting requirements vary by city, so don’t assume your contractor is handling it unless it’s in writing. If someone tells you to skip permits to save time, that’s a red flag. Following the legal process might slow things down up front, but it saves you from headaches down the line.
8. Failing to Communicate Clearly
Assumptions are the silent killers of renovation projects. If you assume your contractor knows what you want without spelling it out, and documenting it, you’re playing a dangerous game. One misunderstood text can lead to thousands in change orders, delays, or mismatched finishes.
Create a clear communication structure from the start. Weekly check-ins, written change orders, and project management tools like Buildertrend or CoConstruct can help keep everyone aligned. Over-communicating might feel redundant, but under-communicating guarantees problems. And don’t just trust verbal agreements, if it’s not in writing, it doesn’t count.
9. Not Thinking Long-Term
You’re designing for your current lifestyle, sure, but what about five or ten years from now? A fully open-concept layout might sound great now, but if you end up working from home long-term or caring for aging parents, you might wish you had a closed office or main-floor bedroom.
Think beyond resale value and focus on how your home can evolve with your needs. Consider accessibility, storage, and multi-functional spaces. You don’t need to go full universal design, but laying some groundwork now, like wider doorways or blocking for future grab bars, can save major renovation headaches later.
10. Overlooking the Resale Value
We’re not saying your home should feel like a beige spec build, but resale should still be on your radar, even if you’re not moving anytime soon. Hyper-personalized choices (like replacing your bathtub with a wine fridge or building a home bowling alley) can make your home harder to sell later, no matter how much you love them.
Before making bold changes, ask yourself: would a potential buyer appreciate this, or see it as something to undo? Renovating for resale doesn’t mean sacrificing personality, it just means making smart decisions with broader appeal.
Conclusion: Renovate With Fewer Regrets
Renovating doesn’t have to be a nightmare, but it can go sideways fast if you’re not prepared. Cost overruns, permit issues, bad hires, and design regret aren’t just common, they’re practically baked into the process for homeowners who jump in without a plan. The good news? Every mistake on this list is avoidable with the right approach and the right team.
It comes down to a few simple principles: plan thoroughly, budget realistically, and work with professionals who actually know what they’re doing. At Roberts Construction Company, we don’t just build for you, we guide you. We help homeowners make informed decisions that hold up over time, both structurally and financially. If you’re thinking about remodeling, let’s talk early, before the demo, before the dust, and definitely before anything gets too expensive to undo.
TL;DR: Renovating your home should be exciting, not a financial black hole. But poor planning, unrealistic budgets, and hiring the wrong contractor can turn your dream remodel into a total nightmare. Here are ten of the most common mistakes homeowners make during a renovation, plus how to avoid them like a pro.
Key Insights
Renovation Mistakes Usually Start Before We Ever Pick Up a Tool
As a contractor, I can tell you—most issues aren’t caused by bad carpentry, they’re caused by rushed decisions and vague plans. Homeowners who skip detailed planning often find themselves making expensive, stressful choices in the middle of the job. That’s why I help clients front-load decisions and lock in details before demo starts.
The Lowest Bid Isn’t a Bargain – It’s a Gamble
I’ve seen firsthand how “budget” contractors cut corners, ghost clients, or walk away mid-job. Hiring the right contractor means looking at credentials, communication, and reputation—not just the price tag. Your home deserves better than the cheapest option on the spreadsheet.
Permits Are a Pain, But Skipping Them Can Cost You Thousands
It’s tempting to rush into a project without dealing with permits. But when you get caught, the fines, delays, and rework are brutal. I always make sure the proper permits are pulled because protecting your home (and your resale value) starts with doing things by the book.
FAQ
